Thursday, December 16, 2010

Kudos to Andrew Sullivan on DADT

The following extended quotation is from today's Andrew Sullivan's blog: http://andrewsullivan.theatlantic.com/He hits the nail on the head about why the repeal of Don't Ask Don't Tell is morally necessary.

"We ask young men and women to go into the line of chaos, hatred and murder in order to keep us safe. Many have gone places and seen things and done things this past decade few of us will ever understand, or be able to appreciate. They have lived with the stress of war and constant deployments that their predecessors never had to cope with. They have encountered enemies prepared to violate every rule of war, to hide among civilians, to exploit the accidental deaths of children and women, and to implement barbaric rule wherever they get a chance to hang their medieval hats.
These men and women deserve our support. Period. All of them. It's inconceivable that in wartime, we should be making any discriminatory exceptions among those who fight for us, that we should honor any of them less than the rest, allow any criterion or characteristic to distract from the simple fact that they are American servicemembers - not gay or straight ones or black or Hispanic or white ones, not male and female ones, but Americans, in the US uniform, whose identity as soldiers begins and ends there.
Some see the end of DADT as some kind of special gesture to a minority. I think they are beyond wrong. This is about moving past the notion of a minority, to a more perfect union, in which nothing irrelevant prevents a man or woman from serving his or her country. It is about attacking the endurance of the gay-straight division and replacing it with the unifying fibre of honor and patriotism. It's about gay Americans being able, finally, in some deep way known only to those who have previously been excluded from military service, to become merely Americans.
Let us lose that qualifying adjective in the service of something greater than ourselves. E pluribus unum."

4 comments:

Russ Manley said...

To be merely Americans . . . what a concept. Let's hope after tomorrow they will be.

Mareczku said...

Good comments here. I commented on the overturning of DADT on a Catholic news site. I said that the Catechism of the Catholic Church says that homosexual persons should be treated with respect and not discriminated against and that overturning DADT was in line with this. Some lady came back and asked me why I was supporting mortal sins. Sigh!

Mareczku said...

Dear Sebastian: Now that I have had my rant I wish you a joyful and blessed Christmas. Enjoy the Christmas holidays. Tomorrow will be busy for me as our choir sings at Mass at 4 PM and also Midnight Mass. Say a prayer for me that
I feel well, that I sing well and that I don't get too tired at the Midnight Mass. Thanks.

Russ Manley said...

Wherever you are, happy new year, Sebastian.